The title card shows some degree of low quality, along with the handheld camerawork that doesn’t always appear intentionally frenetic - but the gore and makeup effects are spot on. The setup isn’t inherently funny, but there’s just enough off about it to foreshadow merriment. Tucker & Dale vs. Evil proceeds to demonstrate the two sides to every story, the two interpretations to every action and the very easy misunderstandings, miscalculations and miscommunications that occur in moments of the unexpected. “Some people just aren’t any good in a crisis,” mutters Dale. The tables are turned on the traditional hunters, killers, torturers, the pursued and survivors, through ludicrous situational comedy.
The premise is ingenious. What this film really needs is some solid marketing and just a touch of tightening in the editing, dialogue and pacing. The evolution of events is generally capable although occasionally contrived. But Tucker and Dale are sensationally purposeful in communicating the story, their characters and laugh-out-loud humor. Dale’s first interaction with the “average” college girls is while holding a threatening scythe and giggling like a lunatic – he chalks up his failure to his tubby face and a slight inferiority complex. Adding to the contrast of their positions, Tucker and Dale aren’t immune to harassment by the local authorities, or the criticisms from one another about immoral activities – despite filling a standardized conception of filth, ignorance and depravity. By the end, they’ll have revealed themselves to be emotional, intelligent, caring and even romantic. It’s the college kids that are the most exaggerated, stereotypical lot (one of each nationality, expectedly); while definitely serving their function, these roles could have been a bit straighter to contrast the goofiness of the leads. The ringleader is appropriately Rambo-esque, however, egging on the mayhem - which is the highlight of this spoof of alone-in-the-woods horror movies and the continual from-bad-to-worse, comedic deterioration of murderous rampages.
- The Massie Twins
