Goodman isn’t a typical leading man, but he does well at the head of a cast of youngsters who aren’t annoying and surprisingly not scripted with every stereotype and cliché for high school kids. His character is convincing as a take on William Castle, who directed such horror films as I Saw What You Did, 13 Ghosts, The Tingler, and House on Haunted Hill, and is notable for his ominous silhouette in a director’s chair puffing on a cigarette. Rather than being concerned with quieting the local hysteria, Woolsey decides to rig his theater with electric shock devices underneath the seats. He’s still from the school of thought wherein monster movies have a villain that can be defeated at the climax so viewers can feel relieved – but he also knows that it takes more and more to scare people, so resorting to creative tactics to supplement the visual frights is the logical next step. It’s still a far reach from what horror films have currently evolved into with imagery only.
Matinee raises questions about moral decency in films, as well as allowing children to see questionable materials and letting them make their own decisions – that could turn them into delinquents. First Amendment rights, role models, negative influences, and “harmless” movie magic are examined with a light, flippant touch that fails to evoke genuine emotions, vocal laughs or suspense. Much of it is also designed strictly for avid ‘50s/’60s sci-fi/horror enthusiasts.
Interestingly, juxtaposing a monster movie with the Cuban Missile Crisis, similar to Them! (1954) which played off of nuclear fears of that decade, is perhaps too deep for this screenplay, which is executed without passion, with faulty pacing and predicaments that are too dull, even for a family-friendly movie. The Mant! footage, however, comprises some of the best bits, cleverly utilizing puns galore, tributes to the actors/studios/fictional characters of such films, and spoofs of comparably low-budget, special effects-laden B-movies - while also paralleling the events unfolding in the real world of the ‘60s (despite being marketed to audiences of 1993).
- Mike Massie