Brave the Dark (2025)

Running Time: 1 hr. 52 min.

MPAA Rating: PG-13

G

arden Spot High School runner Nate Williams (Nicholas Hamilton) seems like a typical teen. He likes to speed in his car and listen to loud music. He’s temperamental, distrustful, and has anger issues. He likes to stay out late, going a bit too far when he steals electronics from a shop to sell for some easy cash. And he even has a girlfriend, Tina Baxter (Sasha Bhasin), whom he responds to with a touch of jealousy and adolescent infatuation. But this seemingly typical student, going through his routines in 1986 in Pennsylvania, harbors an unfortunate, pitiable secret: he’s homeless, living in his car and only staying on the track team to more easily access showers and bathrooms. “I’m not a bad guy.”

Perceptive teacher Stan Deen (Jared Harris) catches on to this, though he too harbors secrets, relating to painful memories that he can’t seem to shake. When the law catches up to Nate, Deen recognizes a wayward youth who just needs a little guidance – rather than a permanently damaged psyche – opting to step in and provide some help, stability, and mentorship. Of course, the fiercely independent kid has to want help; he’ll have to admit he needs it and be big enough to accept it.

Although the opening moments and establishment of characters are terribly generic, cycling through introductions and dialogue that possess not a hint of individuality or originality, it’s difficult to dismiss Harris’ role. He’s not just the most seasoned, natural actor in the picture, but he’s also designed to be exceptionally generous and understanding. He’s marginally like Giamatti’s Hunham from “The Holdovers” (with hints of the educators from “Stand and Deliver” and “Dangerous Minds”), unable not to see the good in people, remaining indefatigably optimistic and mild-mannered. And he’s persistent (and well-connected, humorously, since he’s taught virtually everyone in his small town; “Is there anyone you don’t know?”). When everyone else gives up on Nate, certain that he’s not worth fighting for, Stan digs in, refusing to back down. “Let the system take care of him.”

“Brave the Dark” is also based on a true story, though that isn’t enough to set it apart from the many other films that utilize a comparable premise (“The Blind Side” is one of the first to come to mind). Despite Harris’ engaging persona, Hamilton’s lead and the many supporting roles don’t provoke much of a reaction; they’re simply too ordinary, mere routine components to relate a tale that likewise has minimal twists and turns. It’s about as by-the-numbers as it gets. Plus, when it comes to inspirational underdog yarns, Williams just doesn’t come across as particularly deserving of a big-screen biopic, even if his plight is admittedly dramatic.

There are a few laughs (the dialogue goes out of its way to sound phonily sanitized), wry repetition of the Persian adage “This too shall pass,” clever references to “Flowers for Algernon,” and the extremely slow reveal of a traumatic flashback, among other things, to spruce up the script. But it still rambles, dragging out a largely unadorned plot, going through the predictable steps of portraying a psychologically perturbed teen as he comes to terms with his morbid, formative past – and continuing to mess up on his journey toward redemption. And his uncommonly trusting, lenient, forgiving instructor is always present to provide emotional reenforcement – a concept that sort of cheats when Stan uses the accidentally uncovered truth to bolster his support. By the end, even with effective revelations, worthwhile performances, and a satisfying – if easy and saccharinely sentimental – outcome, “Brave the Dark” manages only to be serviceable; its formulaic method of executing its basic tragedy (as if made solely for a message rather than for genuine entertainment, enabling effortless cynicism), while moseying its way through a daunting, poorly-paced runtime, prevents it from standing out amid its numerous filmic brethren.

– Mike Massie

  • 4/10

Theatrical Release Date: January 15, 2025