Captain America: Brave New World (2025)

Running Time: 1 hr. 58 min.

MPAA Rating: PG-13

A

lmost 100 days into his presidency, Thaddeus “Thunderbolt” Ross (Harrison Ford) has become obsessed with proving to the world – and most importantly to his daughter Betsy (Liv Tyler) – that he has changed for the better. Determined to create a treaty between the United States and the other world powers intent on claiming rare elements from Celestial Island, Ross enlists the aid of the new Captain America, Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie), to take back a top-secret canister stolen from Japan by mercenary group Serpent Society. But when Sam and his protege Joaquin Torres (Danny Ramirez) confront the thieves’ leader, Sidewinder (Giancarlo Esposito), they uncover a conspiracy that will reveal frame-ups, continued assassination attempts, and run-ins with Ross’ highly-skilled head of security, Ruth Bat-Seraph (Shira Haas).

With its timely presidential election theme, there’s something eerily grounded about the politics in “Captain America: Brave New World.” But, of course, the premise must also consider the fact that half of the population disappeared in the blink of an eye, as well as the country’s repeated, deadly battles against alien invasions; no matter how sincere the human side of interactions remains, the outrageous superhero stuff quickly overtakes any semblance of realism. This clash of ideas is apparent in Wilson’s introduction, too, as the foiling of a hostage situation pits supernatural components against plainly normal thugs – a terribly unequal confrontation. Equipped with ludicrous Wakandan technology, which can easily explain away all sorts of physical feats and imperviousness to bullets (essentially, anything can happen, and these additives can be used as flimsy excuses), Wilson’s more-than-human status (essentially just another version of Iron Man) is confirmed (while his new, sarcastic, insolent sidekick is annoying above anything else).

Every time Sam dukes it out with regular people, it’s weirdly anticlimactic and dull. It’s not just that he won’t die because he’s the star; he also feels as if consistently invincible, which definitely doesn’t establish typical underdog sympathies. To create believable conflict, exceptionally manufactured, overly contrived situations must be orchestrated. And yet, when it comes to an average human antagonist like Sidewinder, this overconfident, superpower-less persona manages to simply walk away from Captain America, as if also insusceptible to advanced weaponry. Either way, the early action sequences are routine and unexciting; the umpteenth time that a superhero (or “enhanced individual” as they’re dubbed) engages in martial arts combat rarely musters enthusiasm.

What has changed in this universe, however, is the infusion of politics – at least to the degree represented in this latest chapter. It’s a compelling new reality when every alliance or act of independence can be viewed through an amplified political lens, judging how society will react to fictional warriors siding with partisan players and motives. And rather than having the world unite to face the dangers of otherworldly invaders, the predicaments here concern themselves with how international relationships falter (this is why “Top Gun: Maverick” chose unnamed, unaffiliated evildoers), causing headaches for politicians – easy villains as they may be – as they navigate treaties and (extraterrestrial) resources (as well as uninspired Manchurian Candidate-type tradecraft).

Once again, since this is well into “Phase Five” of Marvel’s cinematic features, minimal explanations are given for the various returning characters. And the script doesn’t just dredge up roles from the last few pictures and television series (leaning heavily on “The Falcon and the Winter Soldier”) – it goes all the way back to “The Incredible Hulk” (2008), whose storyline was arguably retrofitted into the universe entirely, largely appearing as if an independent entry. These references are bizarrely obscure, though they do give hardcore fans a reason to revisit that remarkably forgettable version of the Hulk. Unfortunately, as a result of so many callbacks, these Marvel films are becoming increasingly less friendly for casual moviegoers.

Despite the unwieldy backstories, the events of “Captain America: Brave New World” don’t seem consequential. Decent aerial photography, Ford’s committed acting, and Mackie’s ability to handle the lead part (though he isn’t given particularly unique powers, strong relationships with other characters, or even a love interest) aren’t enough to counter how this entire endeavor feels as if a random episode from a serialized TV show, with no discernible beginning or end, merely reveling, momentarily, in fleeting action and showdowns. The handful of engaging shots or overarching concepts certainly can’t fix the obnoxiousness of the physics or the monumentally stupid addition of the unexplainably red Hulk monster.

– The Massie Twins

  • 4/10

Theatrical Release Date: February 12, 2025