Joker: Folie à Deux (2024)

Running Time: 2 hrs. 18 min.

MPAA Rating: R

P

erhaps setting the stage for just how bizarre “Joker: Folie à Deux” will be, the film opens with a traditionally-animated cartoon entitled “Me and My Shadow,” with the title character engaging in slapstick shenanigans (and a bit of bloodshed) as if in a “Looney Tunes” sketch, illustrating a figuratively fractured identity. An alter ego is causing chaos, but it’s the meeker personality that pays the price – an austere message for a quirky skit, which doesn’t at all fit with the world of “Joker,” though that routinely feels as if the purpose for this direct sequel. “Hey Fleck, you got a joke for us today?”

When the story proper begins, it picks up where the previous one left off (approximately two years later), with Arthur Fleck (Joaquin Phoenix), gaunt and skeletal, contending with a hellish stay at the Arkham State Hospital in Gotham City (here, in New York state, specifically to differentiate this property from the DC Cinematic Universe). He’s physically and emotionally tortured and tormented in the bleak gray environs, often punctuated with grime and rain, but also splashes of color, as if to make note of various elements that are only visible through his eyes. After his five-person killing spree, Fleck faces a trial, with his lawyer (Catherine Keener) hoping to get him a transfer to a real hospital, and not the veritable dungeon he currently inhabits. But it’s going to be an uphill battle; an insanity defense isn’t going to be easy when Arthur continues to enjoy a celebrity status outside the walls, where hordes of followers mimic his clown costuming and makeup, and channel his seemingly antiestablishment rebelliousness.

Still problematic is the fact that the central character is a largely unsympathetic wacko, providing an unreliable narrative perspective. As if the prior film wasn’t unusual enough, removing a popular comic book villain from a sensible fantasy of vigilante justice – wielded by a caped crusader – and placing him firmly in the middle of realistic psychological and economic depressions, this one adds an extra ingredient: songs. It’s actually an unrestrained jukebox musical, with oodles of chipper, classic music playing in the background to alternate with onscreen crooning as Fleck imagines himself having a love-at-first-sight (or love-at-first-blaze) romance with arsonist Lee Quinzel (Lady Gaga), a fellow inmate enjoying greater comforts in her minimum-security wing. Unexpectedly, the songs are superb, essentially lifting recognizable numbers from MGM musicals (like “The Band Wagon”) for various duets and performances by the swooning couple (though a few are dourer, reminiscent of Leos Carax’s “Annette”). At one point, Fleck even gets to tap dance.

It’s quite the jovial occasion, if only intermittently, as these imagined asides pepper the harsher sequences of prison violence and the downsides of extreme mental illnesses. The camaraderie between likeminded criminals lends to powder-keg moments, feeling as if at any second, something jarring and catastrophic might erupt. Yet rarely does this happen, stymied not just by the crawling pacing, but also the hopelessly blurred lines between reality and fiction; since the last film established that not everything visualized is genuine (particularly with Zazie Beetz’ role), audiences are likely to assume that most of what takes place here is only tenuously tied to actuality. Virtually every shot could be fanciful fabrication.

If the picture had delved deeper into how a monstrous persona coaxed Gotham into embracing bedlam and anarchy, how a murderer’s actions inspired fans and copycats, how a strong personality could whip up a cult following, it might have offered worthwhile commentary. Instead, most of the overlong running time is stuffed with awkward, uncomfortable, miserable people trapped in cycles of abuse. The standards of splashy comeuppance or vengeful confrontations don’t even arise; it’s as if director Todd Phillips’ intent is to sap all sense of satisfaction from these characters, as a lesson on deconstructing expectations about the Joker and Harley Quinn – as if to punish viewers for desiring even an inkling of recognizable aspects from these famous supervillains.

Phoenix again gives a tremendous performance, while Gaga is more than adequate as a part-crazy, part-manipulative love interest, but the premise just doesn’t work. Without a superhero to balance out these baddies, they’re entirely isolated from any reason to care about their origins; they may be pitiable, anguished, lost souls suffering from a wealth of disorders, but there’s nothing left to say or add to what was previously established. It’s a variety show set in a snake pit (with components of “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest” and “Marat/Sade,” with a hint of “Angels with Dirty Faces” mixed in), “Sucker Punch” without the titillation, Fritz Lang’s “M” without the forces of righteousness closing in; but very little of it is entertaining. It may be ambitious, inexplicable, and one-of-a-kind, but that so rarely translates into something engaging – or even watchable.

– Mike Massie

  • 2/10

Theatrical Release Date: October 03, 2024