
O. Henry’s Full House (1952)
Running Time: 1 hr. 57 min.
MPAA Rating: Not Rated
N
arrator John Steinbeck, who believes that writers should be read not seen, makes an exception when it comes to social critic, humorist, and esteemed author William Sydney Porter – pen name O. Henry – who has long since passed away. With little delay, he opens up a book and begins to share one short story with the audience: “The Cop and the Anthem.” Soapy (Charles Laughton) is a homeless man who determines that in order to receive free room and board from the state, he’ll have to commit a small crime to land himself in jail. His fellow vagrant, Horace (David Wayne), attempts to talk him out of it, but Soapy is on a mission. When he steals an umbrella – which was previously stolen itself – he’s unable to attract the attention of the police. And so, he opts to dine at a lavish restaurant and order a considerable feast for which he can’t pay. But even that doesn’t get him behind bars as he had hoped. It’s a fascinating tale of luck, as a simple crook just can’t seem to judicially pay for his transgressions; and it’s also quite funny, as he fails repeatedly to take the blame where it’s due. In the end, it’s also a heartwarming nod to second chances and reformation, to unearthing hope and faith amid dire circumstances – and the crushing irony of Soapy’s outcome. Ultimately, however, it’s surely best remembered for a brief, unnamed role by Marilyn Monroe.
In “The Clarion Call,” an NYPD detective (Dale Robertson) investigates a murder by following up on the only lead: an expensive gold pencil. It leads him to ruffian Johnny Kernan (Richard Widmark), an explosive, hotheaded brute who bullies and beats everyone who crosses his path. This one also examines ethical dilemmas as the lawman is forced to confront his shady past. Shifting away from lightheartedness, heavier drama is examined, though the finale provides a humorous, punchy close. It’s evident that O. Henry’s writings are primarily interested in the human condition, scrutinizing how people can change as they deal with attitudes and motives that course correct after periods of hardship or enlightenment.
“The Last Leaf” finds a woman (Anne Baxter) suffering from pneumonia during a blustering winter in Greenwich Village, after a rough breakup with her man. But she requires medicine beyond what the doctor can offer: she has to want to live. While this short subject similarly touches upon emotional elements, it’s the first one in which predicaments are orchestrated that don’t feel as powerful, though the sacrifices made are striking nonetheless. As each chapter unfolds, it’s apparent that O. Henry’s forte is in challenging how normal, relatable, pitiable circumstances can reach beautiful resolutions when perspectives can be transformed. A bit of kindness goes a long way.
“The Ransom of Red Chief” features Fred Allen and Oscar Levant as comically inept confidence men in early 1900s Alabama. When they kidnap a small child for ransom, they’re immediately in over their heads, as the tot is quick, manipulative, and tough-as-nails. And his parents aren’t too concerned with getting their diminutive hellion back. “What is there to worry about?” Like in many anthologies, one of the pieces doesn’t possess the same entertainment value as the others, and this fourth sequence assumes that role. Its insincerity and jokiness prevents it from being as significant, even though the purpose – reminiscent, perhaps, of Aesop’s fables – is worthwhile. Funnily enough, “The Ransom of Red Chief” was so poorly received during the original theatrical run that it was removed for many subsequent showings.
The final story, “The Gift of the Magi,” is one of O. Henry’s most famous. It stars Jeanne Crain as Della Young, whose husband Jim (Farley Granger) wishes to get her a present for Christmas. But they can’t afford to exchange gifts. Still, they have each other, and they’re madly in love – a Dickensian sort of setting and premise. When they eventually do decide on secret presents – a nice chain for his watch and bejeweled pins for her Rapunzel-like hair – the lengths they go to obtain them for one another reveal some devastating, heart-wrenching ironies. “Surprise me.”
Each tale is brief and to the point; this vignette arrangement is the perfect way for O. Henry’s works to come to life, revealing their poignant messages without being stretched thin for the sake of individual, feature-length designs. Plus, it allows for an enormous ensemble cast, directed by renowned filmmakers (including Henry King, Henry Hathaway, and Howard Hawks). And though the five separate entries don’t always fit together well (despite the New York turn-of-the-century settings), it ends on the best one, resulting in a highly memorable production.
– Mike Massie
- 8/10
Theatrical Release Date: October 16, 1952







