
Witness for the Prosecution (1957)
Running Time: 1 hr. 56 min.
MPAA Rating: Not Rated
50s | Legal Thriller | Mystery | W
“J
ust roll up your mouth,” demands Sir Wilfrid Robarts (Charles Laughton) to the nurse, Miss Plimsoll (Elsa Lanchester), who rides alongside him as he’s driven home. Although his staff welcomes his return, Robarts is as irascible and comically cynical as ever, all but dismissing the many attendants who wish him good health. Plimsoll, who maintains a hilariously contentious, combative relationship with her client, elaborates that the pudgy, cane-wielding old barrister wasn’t exactly discharged, but rather expelled from the hospital for conduct unbecoming of a cardiac patient (his biting, impatient prattling sounds periodically based on “The Man Who Came to Dinner”).
Wilfrid isn’t supposed to take any over-stimulating criminal cases (his flagging wellbeing is of constant concern to everyone around him), but when solicitor Mr. Mayhew (Henry Daniell) shows up at his office, carrying a couple of cigars – the kind Robarts is prohibited from enjoying – the insubordinate lawyer is inclined to have a brief chat at the very least. The situation involves out-of-work mechanic (something of a drifter) Leonard Steven Vole (Tyrone Power), who is likely to be arrested for the murder of middle-aged widow Mrs. French, who was bludgeoned to death after having met with Vole. The evidence is all circumstantial, but there’s no reason for him to abandon caution; even if he’s innocent, that isn’t always enough to stop prosecution. Through flashbacks, Vole recounts his initial meetings with Emily Jane French (Norma Varden), his hopes that her wealth might be useful in promoting an invention, and the subsequent sherry and canasta afternoons that surely gave the widow the wrong ideas – considering that Vole is married to actress Christine (Marlene Dietrich).
“No matter how bad things look, I didn’t do it!” With a very handsome motive, no strong alibi, and an insincere attitude (or an inappropriately chipper approach) toward his predicament, Vole’s case will be an uphill battle. And it also doesn’t help that his wife is brittle, emotionless, and generally uncooperative. Perhaps she’s up to something; or perhaps he’s guilty. Either way, Sir Wilfrid becomes so intrigued that, against his doctors’ orders, he decides to defend Vole himself.
“Are you keeping something from me?” Based on Agatha Christie’s international stage success, writer/director Billy Wilder employs plenty of humor in the dialogue, lightening the mood with amusing consistency, punctuating the accumulating evidence weighing against the defendant. Sentimental romance also works its way into the script, creating a few striking moments better fit for a screwball comedy (and opportunities to spy Dietrich’s signature legs). Ultimately, however, this tale is designed to be a nail-biting courtroom thriller (of the powdered wig variety), whose various legal showdowns and prosecutorial twists mark it as one of the most renowned. “She seemed remarkably sane and self-possessed.”
“I’m too old and too sick to go on a wild goose chase.” Once the trial gets underway, Laughton shines as the frequently objecting barrister who phrases his interrogations with staggering eloquence and a hint of disdain, shutting down more than a few of the prosecution’s questions and witnesses (headed by Torin Thatcher as Myers). The battle of legal wits is riveting; the pacing is exceptional, reiterating a few key points while unveiling a greater number of surprises. Although the picture centers upon the titular, hostile witness for the prosecution and the shocks presented from that climactic testimony, it’s Laughton’s performance that remains most memorable. He’s had many tour-de-force turns, but this one feels tailor-made for the revered thespian. Dietrich, despite having a couple of clamorous outbursts, is never quite convincing, even if her part is undoubtedly significant to the film’s success. And while the conclusion is a touch overwrought, the parting shots are terribly satisfying.
– Mike Massie
- 8/10
Theatrical Release Date: December 17, 1957







